Naethra had been keeping track of the conversation, somewhat relieved that most of the party wasn't buying into Oric's line of thinking.
"I think there are a few key, critical differences here you're rather eager to overlook, Oric." She said, softly.
"Firstly, and of least significance I'll admit, many of those people were peasants, farmers, and laborers after their previous lives and professions were taken from them by force, like that one warrior who gave Duran his axe after he had his martial skill ripped out of him. Secondly, they lived under frequent abuse by a gang of marauding, horny rape-monsters that systematically kept from building any degree of security. Thirdly, said monsters were just one of many, many possible ways for them to cease existing as cognizant, independent, functional beings. Others included packs of horny wolves and the very plants that surrounded them. It's not so much that those people can't be things other than farmers, so much as they live in abuse and fear in a strange land where everything is trying to fuck them into oblivion."
She took a breath, "And finally, I'm less concerned about the ordering of that shrine than I am about how this all reeks of a pocket realm, a self-contained reality created and operated by our Gracious Hostess. The absent gods leave us to pick up the pieces on our own. Our Fulsome Matron is, demonstrably, more hands-on. Everything we just saw? Everything we fought through? Everyone we lost? All by her design. This didn't happen by accident. She plays with people's lives, and I sincerely doubt she has much reverence for her toys."
Naethra took a breath, trying to keep herself from getting worked up. Again. Latisha hadn't had a chance to speak, but a question was nagging at the back of Naethra's mind. After a heart-beat's hesitation, she piled it onto the rest she'd asked the barista.
"Just... out of grim curiosity, how many have made it this far?"